Critical Race Theory in Education: Harming Our Children

May 10, 2022

Critical Race Theory (CRT) is a theoretical framework that believes race is at the core of all human interactions and experiences. It seeks to dismantle all forms of power and privilege that people of color experience. Critics of CRT argue that it’s a theory rooted in victimhood, and it paints a bleak and negative picture of the world. They believe that it’s not only damaging to students but also to educators who are trying to provide a positive learning environment for all students.

What is Critical Race Theory?

Critical Race Theory (CRT) is a theoretical framework that believes race is at the core of all human interactions and experiences. It seeks to dismantle all forms of power and privilege that people of color experience.

CRT was developed in the 1980s by a group of professors at the University of California, Los Angeles. The theory was born out of the civil rights movement and the growing awareness that race plays a role in all aspects of life, including education. CRT aims to identify and address the ways in which race shapes individual lives, institutions, and society as a whole.

There are three central tenets of Critical Race Theory:

  1. Racism is everywhere – CRT believes that racism is entrenched in every institution and aspect of life in America.
  2. Racism is intentional – CRT posits that racism is not accidental or unconscious but purposeful and deliberate.
  3. Racism benefits white people – CRT argues that racism is not just harmful to people of color but actually benefits white people in terms of power, privilege, and resources.

What are the criticisms of Critical Race Theory?

Critics of Critical Race Theory argue that it’s a theory rooted in victimhood, and it paints a bleak and negative picture of the world. They believe that it’s not only damaging to students but also to educators who are trying to provide a positive learning environment for all students.

Critics argue that CRT promotes a “race-first” approach that puts race at the center of everything rather than looking at the individual. They also argue that CRT divides people into two groups – oppressors and victims – which leads to a feeling of hopelessness and powerlessness. Additionally, critics believe that CRT does not take into account the progress that has been made in America since the civil rights movement.

What are the implications of Critical Race Theory in education?

The implications of Critical Race Theory in education are significant. By teaching this theory to students, educators are not just introducing them to a theoretical framework but also sending a strong message about the importance of race in society and everyday life. This can have a negative impact on students, especially those who don’t identify as people of color.

Some critics believe that Critical Race Theory actually perpetuates racism by presenting it as a normal, inevitable part of life. Additionally, some argue that CRT creates divisions between different groups of people based on race or ethnicity, which further reinforces stereotypes and prejudices.

Despite these criticisms, many educators continue to embrace Critical Race Theory and incorporate it into their curricula. However, there is still much debate about the usefulness and effectiveness of CRT in education today. Ultimately, it is up to individual educators and schools to decide whether or not Critical Race Theory should be included in their curricula.

How does CRT harm students and educators?

There are many ways in which Critical Race Theory can harm students and educators. By teaching this theory to students, educators are not just introducing them to a theoretical framework but also sending a strong message about the importance of race in society and everyday life. This can have a negative impact on students, especially those who don’t identify as people of color.

Some critics believe that CRT promotes a “race-first” approach, which puts race at the center of everything and ignores other important factors. Furthermore, by focusing so heavily on racism and power dynamics, CRT can actually be harmful to students by reinforcing negative stereotypes about people of color.

Additionally, some argue that CRT disempowers students and creates divisions between different groups of people, which can lead to feelings of hopelessness and disengagement.

What are the alternatives to CRT in education?

There are several alternatives to Critical Race Theory in education. One approach is to focus on individual stories and experiences rather than viewing the world through a racial lens. Another is to take a more nuanced and multifaceted approach to understanding race and racism without automatically attributing actions or behavior to racist motives.

Finally, some educators argue that it’s important to acknowledge both the successes and failures of the civil rights movement while also recognizing that much work still needs to be done in terms of equality and justice. Ultimately, there is no single “right” approach to teaching about race – what matters most is finding effective strategies that help students grow, learn, and thrive.

How can we work to dismantle racism in our schools and communities?

There are many ways that we can work to dismantle racism in our schools and communities. One approach is to focus on teaching about individual experiences and stories rather than viewing the world through a racial lens. This can help us understand the complex, nuanced nature of race and power dynamics without automatically attributing actions or behavior to racist motives.

Another important strategy is to take a more multifaceted approach to understand racism and its impacts. We should acknowledge both the successes and failures of the civil rights movement while also recognizing that there is still much work left to be done in terms of equality and justice.

Finally, it is essential that we involve students in efforts to combat racism and promote diversity in our schools and communities. This might include organizing dialogues and workshops, creating school-wide initiatives or programs, or partnering with local organizations to advance racial justice. By working together, we can create more inclusive and equitable learning environments that are truly welcoming to all students.

There are 30 million Christians in the United States who don’t use their voice to change policy. But your voice does matter. Especially when a million of us speak at once to those that have the power to change things — the policymakers in this country. And the policymakers have told us the number one thing that changes their position regarding issues is when a constituent from their district mails them a signed note. So sign for Million Voices and use your voice today.