Islamic Cities Signal Concerns About American Culture Shift

Mitchel Lensink, Unsplash

America has long seen immigration as a source of renewal and strength. Yet in January 2025, the Center for Immigration Studies reported that the foreign-born population, legal and illegal, reached 53.3 million, or 15.8% of the total U.S. population. That share is higher than any time in U.S. history, even surpassing the peaks of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, and the results are showing up across the nation, in the New York City mayoral race, among other political concerns across the nation. 

Such a scale of immigration carries profound implications for communities, public services, the labor market, and the shared identity of this nation. 

Shifting Cultural Foundations and Local Impact 

When a society experiences this level of demographic change, the cultural and civic foundations that once held broadly shared meaning can become strained. With so many newcomers, each bringing their own backgrounds, languages, religious beliefs, and customs, the question arises: how will the shared “American identity” adapt or hold together? 

In many neighborhoods, changes in population have shifted local norms. Schools are adjusting to multilingual classrooms. Places of worship are changing, and civic institutions are working to engage more diverse constituencies. 

A city in Michigan is seeing this first-hand. Hamtramck, Michigan, America’s first and only all-Muslim City Council, recently voted to rename on of the city’s main roads to “Palestine Avenue” in response to the Israel-Hamas war. 

According to Detroit Free Press, “Hamtramck has the highest percentage of immigrants anywhere in Michigan, the biggest concentration of Bangladeshi immigrants in the state and the second-highest percentage of Arab residents after Dearborn. According to Census data, more than 40% of the city is foreign-born and almost 70% of its residents are Muslim, including the mayor, the police chief and the entire city council, whose members all are men.” 

This signals a growing trend of Muslim influence in American cities, a growing concern for many Americans. 

Michigan is not alone, a Muslim-exclusive community in Texas, called East Plano Islamic Center or EPIC, was in the process of being built, until Texas Governor Greg Abbott put an immediate cease on the project, asserting that this is an attempt to establish Islamic law in Texas. “To be clear, Sharia law is not allowed in Texas. Nor are Sharia cities. Nor are ‘no go zones’ which this project seems to imply…” 

Assimilation, Values, and Shared Civic Life 

Assimilation has always been part of the American story. Newcomers adopt English, embrace civic participation, and contribute to communal life. But when the immigrant share grows rapidly, the pace and scale of cultural blending accelerate, sometimes faster than institutions can adjust. 

According to the same CIS report, between January 2021 and January 2025 the foreign-born population grew by 8.3 million, more than the total growth in the preceding 12 years. 

Experts note that the workforce share of immigrants is rising, and that the native-born without a bachelor’s degree are increasingly out of the labor force. This shift raises important questions about economic integration and social cohesion.  

When a large new population arrives, cultural integration is not automatic. It depends on language acquisition, civic engagement, a common understanding of rights and duties, and shared public discourse. Without these, the risk is that communities drift into parallel social worlds rather than one shared civic world. 

America’s Assimilation Problem 

The record-breaking figures are concerning because they indicate a significant increase in immigration of people who hate America, though not everyone. What is concerning is not immigration itself, but those who are coming in, who do not share the same values that many natural-born citizens are raised with. This is why assimilation is important. 

Will the institutions of civil society, schools, faith communities, civic organizations, work proactively to weave newcomers into the fabric of “we the people”? Or will the sense of “American identity” become too diffuse, losing the moral and civic core that once held a more unified culture together? 

Some solutions are already visible. English-language programs, civics courses for new citizens, and local efforts to foster cross-cultural community service help nurture the mindset that being American is about ideas and civic purpose as much as background. However, many believe these solutions are too late. America’s border policies have allowed immigration, particularly open-border immigration for far too long, without any process of assimilation at all. 

What remains is the broader question: how does America maintain her values, customs and traditions with so many immigrants living here, whose values are in opposition to the traditional American way of life? 

The coming decades will test that capacity. 

Contacting your representatives should be easy, but there are myriad ways they can ignore your messages. That’s where we come in.             

Yes, Million Voices helps you with voter guides. Yes, we send letters from YOU directly to your elected officials because it’s the only way to guarantee they’ll listen to you. Yes, we publish data, articles, text messages, and help bridge the gap between education and civic action. But what do you want? Tell us today.            

We want to make YOU the hero of our American story by giving you the tools you need to make a difference, from your local, state, all the way up to the federal level.            

Join us in our mission to advocate for religious freedom, support fair and secure elections, and uphold the values that this great nation was built upon. Tell us what you want from the next four years, and we will fight to make it a reality … again!