30 Million Undocumented: Margolin’s Immigration Strategy

Nils Huenerfuerst, Unsplash

President Donald Trump has appointed a new leader to oversee the nation’s immigration courts, and he is already making headlines. Daren Margolin, the new director of the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR), recently shared startling numbers regarding the population of people in the country illegally. His estimates suggest the situation is far more difficult than government data previously indicated.

In a recent Axios interview, Margolin stated that he believes there are between 25 million and 30 million people in the United States illegally. This figure is significantly higher than the official estimates often cited by government agencies. Most official data places the number closer to 11 million or 14 million people.

Margolin’s high estimate highlights the massive challenge facing the current administration. As the new immigration judge chief, he is tasked with managing a court system that is already overwhelmed. The administration is currently working to clear a backlog of millions of pending cases.

The backlog in immigration courts currently stands at more than 3.6 million cases. Margolin warned that there will likely never be enough judges to handle every single case if the numbers continue to grow. This reality is driving the administration to find new ways to speed up the process.

Margolin officially took over the agency in October, bringing a strict new vision to the role. He previously served as an immigration judge but retired early in 2024. He stated that he left because he disagreed with how the previous administration handled the southern border crisis.

He expressed strong feelings about his time working under the previous policies. Margolin told reporters that he felt like a “co-conspirator in treason” during that period. Now back in charge, he is focused on implementing major changes to the system.

Speeding Up Deportation Efforts in the Courts

The primary goal for the new director is to streamline how cases are handled. By moving cases through the court faster, the administration hopes to assist deportation efforts across the country. When courts rule quickly, immigration officers can enforce the law more effectively.

One major strategy involves limiting the appeals process for those facing removal orders. Currently, people can appeal decisions, which drags out the legal process for months or even years. Margolin wants to shorten this timeline to ensure final decisions are made much faster.

If the appeals process is limited, it could lead to a higher number of expedited deportations. This means people found to be in the country illegally would be returned to their home countries much sooner. This is a key part of the administration’s broader plan to secure the border.

Data shows that the backlog of cases has already started to drop. Since President Trump’s inauguration last year, the number of pending cases has decreased by over 340,000. This decline is partly due to a drop in new border crossings.

Fewer people crossing the border means fewer new cases are being added to the court dockets. This gives judges a chance to catch up on the millions of older cases still waiting for a decision. However, the workload remains incredibly heavy for the current staff.

To help with the workload, the agency has launched a campaign to hire more judges. The office received about 1,700 applications recently and is working to get new judges on the bench. Margolin confirmed that the first group of new hires will begin working within days.

In addition to civilian judges, Margolin is bringing in help from the military. He has recruited roughly 50 temporary military attorneys to assist with the caseload. These officers will undergo the same training as other hires to ensure they are ready.

Analyzing the Numbers and the Strategy

The difference between Margolin’s estimate of 30 million and official stats is a major point of discussion. Official sources, such as the Department of Homeland Security and the Pew Research Center, have reported much lower numbers; recent Pew data placed the unauthorized immigrant population at a record 14 million in 2023. Margolin’s figure suggests that illegal immigration could be nearly double what many experts have published.

If there truly are 30 million people here illegally, the court system will need massive resources to process them all. The current backlog of 3.6 million represents only a fraction of that total population. This discrepancy explains why Margolin is so focused on speed and efficiency.

Margolin’s background helps explain his disciplined approach to the job. He is a retired Marine Corps colonel with over two decades of military service. His experience includes time as a military judge and a prosecutor.

Before taking this top leadership role, he worked as an assistant chief counsel for Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). He also served as an assistant chief immigration judge in California from 2020 to 2024. This mix of military and legal experience shapes his aggressive strategy.

The use of military lawyers is an unconventional move that shows how urgent the administration considers the problem. By using Judge Advocate General (JAG) officers, the agency can quickly boost its workforce. These officers are used to operating in structured, high-pressure environments.

Critics of the new policies may argue that speeding up cases could hurt due process. However, supporters argue that the system has been broken for too long and needs drastic action. For Margolin, the priority is clearing the backlog and enforcing the law.

The administration views the immigration courts as the next phase of its enforcement operation. While border patrol agents stop people at the line, judges determine who stays and who goes. Without a functioning court system, enforcement efforts at the border can get stalled.

The Future of Immigration Enforcement

As these new policies take effect, the country will likely see an increase in final removal orders. The decline in the backlog is a promising sign for the administration’s goals. However, the sheer volume of cases remains a massive hurdle to overcome.

The reported drop in border crossings during President Trump’s first year back in office has provided some relief. This pause allows the courts to focus on the millions of people already in the system. But if Margolin’s 30 million estimate is accurate, the work has only just begun.

The focus on limiting appeals will likely be the most controversial change. It fundamentally alters how the immigration court system has operated for years. This change is designed to stop people from using the legal system to delay their departure.

For everyday Americans, these changes signal a return to stricter enforcement of immigration laws. The administration is signaling that entering the country illegally will have swift consequences. The goal is to restore order to a system that many believe has been chaotic for too long.

Margolin’s leadership marks a significant shift in tone and policy for the agency. His willingness to speak bluntly about “treason” and “illegal totals” sets him apart from past directors. He is clearly aligned with President Trump’s vision for a secure nation.

As the new judges and military attorneys start work, the speed of processing will be the key metric to watch. If the backlog continues to drop, the administration will view it as a success. The coming months will determine if this aggressive approach can truly fix the system.

Ultimately, the success of these deportation efforts relies on the courts functioning efficiently. With Daren Margolin at the helm, the agency is moving toward a faster, more rigid process. Whether the system can handle the potential 30 million cases remains to be seen.

Contacting your representatives should be easy, but there are myriad ways they can ignore your messages. That’s where we come in. 

Yes, Million Voices helps you with voter guides. Yes, we send letters from YOU directly to your elected officials because it’s the only way to guarantee they’ll listen to you. Yes, we publish data, articles, text messages, and help bridge the gap between education and civic action. But what do you want? Tell us today.

We want to make YOU the hero of our American story by giving you the tools you need to make a difference, from your local, state, all the way up to the federal level.

Join us in our mission to advocate for religious freedom, support fair and secure elections, and uphold the values that this great nation was built upon. Tell us what you want from the next four years, and we will fight to make it a reality … again!