Chicago Train Attack Raises Questions Over Judicial Release

Charles Forerunner, Unsplash

Last weekend, commuters on Chicago’s Blue Line watched an ordinary train ride turn into a nightmare. According to reporting from the Daily Wire, 26-year-old Bethany MaGee was riding the train when a man walked up to her, doused her in gasoline, and set her on fire. Witnesses say the attack was sudden, deliberate, and completely unprovoked. 

MaGee suffered severe burns and remains in critical condition as her family and friends wait for updates and pray she survives. The horror of this attack is bad enough on its own. But what has stunned the public even more is what came out afterward about the man accused of nearly burning her alive. 

Authorities identified the suspect as 50-year-old Lawrence Reed, a man with a criminal history that most people would assume should have kept him far away from the public. That assumption turned out to be tragically wrong. 

A Violent Record That Never Seemed to Matter 

The Daily Wire reports that Reed had 72 prior arrests on his record before this attack. Seventy-two. The New York Post describes him as a “career criminal” with a long history of violent and unpredictable behavior. Yet he was still walking freely through the city, able to buy gasoline, board a train, and carry out an attack that has now shocked the nation. 

The Post further reports that Reed was on pretrial release and electronic monitoring at the time of the attack. Prosecutors and officials had already seen the pattern. They did not need a crystal ball to recognize the danger. They had his record, his behavior, and years of evidence that this man posed a real threat to the public. 

That is why this case feels less like a random act of violence and more like the result of a system that refuses to take its own warnings seriously. When 72 priors are not enough to keep a dangerous man behind bars, many Americans are questioning what, if anything, will be. 

Warnings to the Court and a Deadly Decision 

What makes this story especially disturbing is that the judge in Reed’s case was not operating in the dark. The Post reports that the judge was explicitly warned that Reed was a “real and present threat.” Prosecutors recommended that he be kept in custody. Despite those warnings, the court allowed him to remain free on pretrial release. 

This is not a small oversight or a paperwork mistake. It is a conscious decision that weighed a repeat violent offender’s freedom more heavily than the safety of ordinary people like Bethany MaGee. When judges choose leniency over clear evidence of danger, the public pays the price. 

The consequences are now heartbreakingly clear. As Newsmax notes, MaGee’s attack has become a national symbol of the growing fear that America’s big cities are trapped in a cycle of crime and release. Residents see the pattern: violent offenders are arrested, warned about, released, and then strike again. Each time, citizens are told the system is “working as intended.” But from the outside, it looks like the system is working against the very people it is supposed to protect. 

Public Outrage Erupts Online 

The attack has also ignited an online firestorm. Commentators and everyday citizens alike have taken to social media to express grief, anger, and disbelief. Conservative commentator Benny Johnson is among those using his platform on X to highlight the case and call out what he sees as a massive failure of leadership. His post is one of many fueling the national discussion about judges who keep giving second, third, and even seventy-second chances to known violent offenders. 

Public reaction on X reflects widespread outrage, with users questioning how a repeat violent offender remained free and expressing renewed concerns about safety on Chicago’s transit system. 

Bethany MaGee is currently fighting for her life because a career criminal with 72 arrests was allowed to walk free.

He soaked her in gasoline and set her on fire on a Chicago train while saying “Burn b*tch.”

This monster should have been behind bars a long time ago.

Judges… pic.twitter.com/MPDZZjk4z8

— Benny Johnson (@bennyjohnson) November 23, 2025

The frustration is not directed only at one judge. It is aimed at a mindset that seems to place ideology over reality. When courts and city leaders push policies that favor automatic release and low accountability, they send a message that even the worst repeat offenders can expect leniency. The result is a rising sense that law-abiding citizens no longer come first. 

System at a Crossroads 

Meanwhile, officials are scrambling to respond. Fox News reports that Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy not only identified MaGee publicly but also blasted Chicago’s “carelessness” in allowing someone with Reed’s history to remain free. He pointed directly to the 72 prior arrests and called the case a devastating example of how soft-on-crime decisions put innocent people in danger. 

The Fox News coverage underscores a simple but important point: this was preventable. Reed did not need more chances. He needed to be restrained from harming anyone else. Instead, the system gambled with public safety, and Bethany MaGee is now paying the price. 

This case places Chicago and the country at a crossroads. Leaders can continue defending policies that leave violent offenders on the streets, or they can start listening to the warnings from prosecutors, law enforcement, and the public. Judges can continue taking risks with other people’s lives, or they can treat patterns of violence as the bright red alarms they are. 

For now, a young woman is fighting for her life because those alarms were ignored. Her story is a sobering reminder that public safety is not an abstract policy debate. It is the difference between life and death for people who are simply trying to get home from work, ride a train, or live their lives in peace. 

Contacting your representatives should be easy, but there are myriad ways they can ignore your messages. That’s where we come in.     

Yes, Million Voices helps you with voter guides. Yes, we send letters from YOU directly to your elected officials because it’s the only way to guarantee they’ll listen to you. Yes, we publish data, articles, text messages, and help bridge the gap between education and civic action. But what do you want? Tell us today.    

We want to make YOU the hero of our American story by giving you the tools you need to make a difference, from your local, state, all the way up to the federal level.    

Join us in our mission to advocate for religious freedom, support fair and secure elections, and uphold the values that this great nation was built upon. Tell us what you want from the next four years, and we will fight to make it a reality … again!