PA Church Battles Township Over Chapel Rights

Channel 82, Unsplash

A battle for religious freedom is unfolding in Collier Township, Pennsylvania, where Holy Trinity Ukrainian Catholic Church is standing firm against government overreach. The church, a spiritual home for a community that fled persecution, now faces hostility in the very nation that promises liberty. This is a critical moment for all believers, as the outcome of this case will send a powerful message about the right to worship freely in America.

Holy Trinity sought to build a chapel on its 41-acre property, a place for prayer, worship, and community service. However, Collier Township officials have blocked their plans, imposing crippling restrictions and denying necessary permits. This blatant discrimination has forced the church to seek justice in federal court, represented by First Liberty Institute, Troutman Pepper Locke, and the Independence Law Center.

Township Imposes Unjust Restrictions

The church’s vision was to construct a chapel with facilities for prayer and worship, continuing a faith tradition that has sustained its people for generations. Instead of receiving fair treatment, they were met with hostility. The township imposed unreasonable and unlawful conditions that strike at the heart of the church’s religious practices.

These restrictions include limits on when and how long church bells can ring, who can be honored in memorial services, and even the size and height of their proposed buildings. Such actions represent a government trying to control how a church worships, a clear violation of our God-given and constitutionally protected rights. It is an injustice that a community that escaped the iron fist of communism must now fight for its freedom on American soil.

The township’s actions reveal a disturbing double standard. While Holy Trinity is being stifled, secular organizations in the same zoning district are given free rein. Less than a mile from the church’s property, a local carpenters’ union operates a 19-acre campus with conference rooms, a cafeteria, and a large event space. This clear discrimination is at the center of the Holy Trinity Church lawsuit.

Legal Grounds for the Lawsuit

Attorneys for Holy Trinity argue that the township is violating both the First Amendment and federal law. The Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act (RLUIPA) was passed specifically to prevent this kind of discrimination. This law ensures that religious institutions are not subjected to zoning laws that are more restrictive than those applied to non-religious assemblies.

The lawsuit asserts that the Collier Township zoning dispute is a clear case of treating a church on unequal terms with secular counterparts. Amusement parks, fitness centers, and country clubs are permitted to operate in the same district, yet a house of worship is being unfairly targeted. This is not just unequal treatment; it is an attack on the free exercise of religion.

Jeremy Dys, Senior Counsel for First Liberty, stated, “The Township has shown clear discrimination in applying strict limitations on the church but giving free rein to comparable secular activities.” This case is a defining moment for religious land use rights across the nation. A victory for Holy Trinity will be a victory for every church that seeks to use its property to serve God and its community without government interference.

A History of Faith and Persecution

The story of Holy Trinity is a powerful testament to faith and resilience. The church is part of a Ukrainian Catholic tradition that suffered brutal repression under the Soviet Union. Its members are descendants of refugees who came to America seeking freedom to worship in peace, according to their ancient customs.

Father Jason Charron, pastor of Holy Trinity, simply states, “We are a parish that seeks to worship freely and serve the needs of the community while being treated fairly and equally.” The restrictions imposed by the township, such as prohibiting All Souls’ Saturday services for those who died before a certain date, directly interfere with their sacred traditions. It is a bitter irony that this congregation now faces such hostility from its local government.

This is more than a legal dispute over land use; it is a spiritual battle for the soul of our nation. When a government can tell a church how to mourn its dead and when to ring its bells, religious freedom itself is in peril. We must stand with Holy Trinity as they fight for the rights that protect all Americans.

A Call for Justice and Action

The church has filed for a preliminary injunction to stop the township from enforcing these discriminatory ordinances. This legal action asks the court to allow the church to proceed with its building plans while the case is heard. The fight is far from over, and the church needs the prayers and support of believers across the country.

This is a moment to use our voices. We must hold our elected officials accountable and demand that they uphold the constitutional rights that are the bedrock of our nation. The case of Holy Trinity is a reminder that freedom is never permanently won but must be defended by each generation.

Let us pray for the leadership of Holy Trinity Ukrainian Catholic Church and for the legal teams fighting on their behalf. Pray that the courts recognize the injustice being done and rule in favor of religious liberty. Your support can help ensure that churches across America remain free to fulfill their God-given missions.

Contacting your representatives should be easy, but there are myriad ways they can ignore your messages. That’s where we come in. 

Yes, Million Voices helps you with voter guides. Yes, we send letters from YOU directly to your elected officials because it’s the only way to guarantee they’ll listen to you. Yes, we publish data, articles, text messages, and help bridge the gap between education and civic action. But what do you want? Tell us today.

We want to make YOU the hero of our American story by giving you the tools you need to make a difference, from your local, state, all the way up to the federal level.

Join us in our mission to advocate for religious freedom, support fair and secure elections, and uphold the values that this great nation was built upon. Tell us what you want from the next four years, and we will fight to make it a reality … again!